• español
    • English
  • Login
  • español 
    • español
    • English
  • Tipos de Publicaciones
    • bookbook partconference objectdoctoral thesisjournal articlemagazinemaster thesispatenttechnical documentationtechnical report
Ver ítem 
  •   IMDEA Networks Principal
  • Ver ítem
  •   IMDEA Networks Principal
  • Ver ítem
JavaScript is disabled for your browser. Some features of this site may not work without it.

Do You Get What You Pay For? Comparing the Privacy Behaviors of Free vs. Paid Apps

Compartir
Ficheros
Do_You_Get_What_You_Pay_For_2019_EN.pdf (530.8Kb)
Identificadores
URI: http://hdl.handle.net/20.500.12761/691
Metadatos
Mostrar el registro completo del ítem
Autor(es)
Han, Catherine; Reyes, Irwin; Elazari Bar On, Amit; Reardon, Joel; Feal, Álvaro; Egelman, Serge; Vallina-Rodriguez, Narseo
Fecha
2019-05-23
Resumen
It is commonly assumed that the availability of “free” mobile apps comes at the cost of consumer privacy, and that paying for apps could offer consumers protection from behavioral advertising and long-term tracking. This work empirically evaluates the validity of this assumption by investigating the degree to which “free” apps and their paid premium versions differ in their bundled code, their declared permissions, and their data collection behaviors and privacy practices. We compare pairs of free and paid apps using a combination of static and dynamic analysis. We also examine the differences in the privacy policies within pairs. We rely on static analysis to determine the requested permissions and third-party SDKs in each app; we use dynamic analysis to detect sensitive data collected by remote services at the network traffic level; and we compare text versions of privacy policies to identify differences in the disclosure of data collection behaviors. In total, we analyzed 1,505 pairs of free Android apps and their paid counterparts, with free apps randomly drawn from the Google Play Store’s category-level top charts. Our results show that over our corpus of free and paid pairs, there is no clear evidence that paying for an app will guarantee protection from extensive data collection. Specifically, 48% of the paid versions reused all of the same third-party libraries as their free versions, while 56% of the paid versions inherited all of the free versions’ Android permissions to access sensitive device resources (when considering free apps that include at least one third-party library and request at least one Android permission). Additionally, our dynamic analysis reveals that 38% of the paid apps exhibit all of the same data collection and transmission behaviors as their free counterparts. Our exploration of privacy policies reveals that only 45% of the pairs provide a privacy policy of some sort, and less than 1% of the pairs overall have policies that differ between free and paid versions.
Compartir
Ficheros
Do_You_Get_What_You_Pay_For_2019_EN.pdf (530.8Kb)
Identificadores
URI: http://hdl.handle.net/20.500.12761/691
Metadatos
Mostrar el registro completo del ítem

Listar

Todo IMDEA NetworksPor fecha de publicaciónAutoresTítulosPalabras claveTipos de contenido

Mi cuenta

Acceder

Estadísticas

Ver Estadísticas de uso

Difusión

emailContacto person Directorio wifi Eduroam rss_feed Noticias
Iniciativa IMDEA Sobre IMDEA Networks Organización Memorias anuales Transparencia
Síguenos en:
Comunidad de Madrid

UNIÓN EUROPEA

Fondo Social Europeo

UNIÓN EUROPEA

Fondo Europeo de Desarrollo Regional

UNIÓN EUROPEA

Fondos Estructurales y de Inversión Europeos

© 2021 IMDEA Networks. | Declaración de accesibilidad | Política de Privacidad | Aviso legal | Política de Cookies - Valoramos su privacidad: ¡este sitio no utiliza cookies!